Stop the Presses for Labor Day

The North American holiday actually has its roots in a newspaper strike in Toronto; a fight over toxic working conditions.

Public Domain. First American Labor Day parade

American histories of Labor Day often give credit to a certain Peter J. McGuire, general secretary of the Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners in New York City. In 1882 he proposed a holiday celebrating the working people, “who from rude nature have delved and carved all the grandeur we behold.” The first parade was a big success; in an article titled "In 1882, Labor Day originated with a parade held in NYC" in 6sqft, Emily Nonko writes, “Along the route, which passed Canal Street on its way to Union Square, hundreds of seamstresses hung out the windows cheering the procession, blowing kisses and waving their handkerchiefs. It’s said as many as 20,000 men marched that day.”

But did Labor Day really originate with a parade in NYC? Where did McGuire get the idea?

A decade earlier in 1872, labor unions were illegal in Canada, but the printing trades were fed up; they were working 12 hours a day, six days a week, exposed to poisons like lead, antimony, and solvents. There were deadly accidents from steam-driven presses. Demanding better working conditions, printers formed the Toronto Printers Union, went on strike, and marched on the Provincial Parliament. Joined by other workers, 10,000 participants – fully a tenth of the city’s population – showed up.

Newspaper publishers, led by George Brown of the Globe (which became the Globe and Mail), fought back. According to Canadian History in an article titled "The First Labour Day," Brown brought in workers from "nearby towns to replace the printers. He even took legal action to quell the strike and had the strike leaders charged and arrested for criminal conspiracy.”

Prime Minister John A. Macdonald, who was always fighting with Brown, sided with the union, passed the Trade Union Act which decriminalized unions, and got the strike leaders released from jail. From that year on (originally in June to celebrate the Act), labor celebrated the event: "The parade that was held in support of the strikers carried over into an annual celebration of worker’s rights and was adopted in cities throughout Canada."

Labour Day on Queen Street, Toronto
Labour Day on Queen Street, Toronto.  Toronto Public Library/Public Domain

On July 22, 1882, the Toronto Trades and Labour Council invited New York's Peter J. McGuire, also a co-founder of the American Federation of Labor, to speak at one of those labor celebrations in Toronto. He liked what he saw; according to Wikipedia, “Returning to the United States, McGuire and the Knights of Labor organised a similar parade based on the Canadian event on 5 September 1882 in New York City, USA.”

Most of the world celebrates Labor on May 1, the anniversary of the Haymarket Riot in Chicago in 1886. But as Brendan Koerner wrote in Slate, that was a problem in the United States.

Though May 1 became an important day for Socialists and Communists, state governments and less radical labor leaders feared that the date was too emotionally charged. In 1894, after President Grover Cleveland ordered the brutal suppression of the Pullman Strike, he realized that he had to do something to curry favor with the labor movement, which viewed him with contempt. Worried that a May 1 holiday would encourage rabble-rousing in commemoration of the Haymarket Riot, he followed the lead of several states and made the first Monday in September a federal holiday in honor of working people.

The Canadian government, also worried about commies and looking to give people an end of summer holiday, followed suit, and that’s how North America got a holiday at the end of summer break.

Labor day in NYC
Labor Day in New York City.  Public Domain

I had never seen any American acknowledgment of the Canadian angle to Labor Day until this Daily News coverage, which ends:

"Oddly enough, the American holiday’s roots extend into Canada. In December 1872, Canadian workers organized a parade to support a strike by the Toronto Typographical Union — whose members were working a 58-hour week. The march became an annual event in the Great White North."

So stop the presses, close that computer and go outside. Through American Peter J. McGuire, you can trace Labor Day right back to the toxic working conditions at the Toronto Globe. It is a holiday celebrating labor, but also a celebration of a cleaner, safer working environment.