News Animals New Yorkers Keep Calm and Carry-On in Hilarious Defiance of Subway Ban on Dogs By Christian Cotroneo Social Media Editor Brock University Carleton University Christian Cotroneo is the social media editor at Treehugger. He is a founding editor at HuffPost Canada, and former writer at The Dodo and Toronto Star. our editorial process Christian Cotroneo Updated September 05, 2019 A dog inside a carrier on the subway. PARALAXIS/Shutterstock Share Twitter Pinterest Email News Environment Business & Policy Science Animals Home & Design Current Events Treehugger Voices It's easy to forget that it’s been almost a year since New York City banned big dogs from the subway system. The official edict came down from city officials last October: No dogs allowed unless the animal fits in a carrier or bag. The idea was, presumably, to make other passengers feel safer — and maybe give them one less reason to smile or look up from their phones on that long, dark commute of the soul. So you might think only pugs and chihuahuas and other portable pooches would be left to chew up the subway scenery. Well, it turns out that many New Yorkers walk softly and carry a big bag. Big enough for a best friend or two. Rather than curb big dog sightings, the ban has turned the subway system into a carnival of canines. People are coming up with the most hilariously inventive ways to make sure their dogs abide by the letter of the law. And, along the way, the ban may actually be bringing people together. According to the New York Times, only 219 riders were issued summonses in 2015, compared to 261 the previous year. Does that suggest the ban wasn’t necessary in the first place? Does it even matter? Because this seems like a winning situation all around: Dog owners get to keep calm and carry-on, subway travelers get something to smile about ... and bureaucrats still get their bone.