Home & Garden Home Eco-Friendly Toilet Paper: Bamboo vs. Recycled By Olivia Young Olivia Young Twitter Writer Ohio University Olivia Young is a writer and green living expert passionate about tiny living, climate advocacy, and all things nature. She holds a degree in Journalism from Ohio University. Learn about our editorial process Published February 28, 2021 recep-bg / Getty Images Share Twitter Pinterest Email Home Green Living Pest Control Natural Cleaning DIY Family Thrift & Minimalism Sustainable Eating It doesn't take an expert to realize that mowing down forests for single-use paper products is poor environmental practice — not least when handfuls of said product are being literally flushed down the toilet thousands of times per second. According to a 2019 Natural Resources Defense Council report titled "The Issue With Tissue," the U.S. leads the world in toilet paper consumption, with the average American going through 28 pounds of it per year. That translates to 141 rolls per person, nearly 50 billion rolls in total, and most of them hail from Canada's boreal forest, which is home to entire populations of caribou, lynx, and moose, not to mention some 600 Indigenous communities. What's more, these trees play an essential role in absorbing and storing earth-heating carbon, which is promptly released back into the atmosphere when the forest is cut. For years, the NRDC has been urging consumers to switch to greener alternatives — namely recycled or bamboo toilet paper (if not the most sustainable option yet, the trusty bidet). Here's a look at how each ranks in eco-friendliness, considering its manufacturing processes, pollution, harvesting methods, and bleaching. How to Choose Paper Products That Protect Forests The best way to make sure your paper products are sourced responsible is to look for their environmental certifications. The Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) certification is the gold standard, ensuring products "come from responsibly managed forests that provide environmental, social, and economic benefits." It can be used for bamboo products, too. The FSC's "tick tree" logo is perhaps the most widely recognized of the paper industry. The Sustainable Forestry Initiative also offers a certification, but it's not as stringent as the FSC's, according to past reports by Green America and Greener Choices. Bamboo Toilet Paper Serhii Ivashchuk / Getty Images Bamboo is quickly gaining traction as a tree-free toilet paper option. Bamboo paper products are manufactured in much the same way as regular paper — the plant is broken down into fibers and turned into a pulp that is then pressed and dried — but whereas the average conifer takes a year to grow one foot, bamboo can manage that growth in one measly hour. It is, in fact, the fastest-growing plant in the world. It's not picky about where it grows, either. Bamboo crops can thrive in a variety of climates. They occupy less space than boreal forests, don't need to be replanted once harvested, and don't require the use of fertilizers or pesticides. Bamboo products produce 30% fewer emissions than those made of virgin fiber, according to the NRDC. Environmental Pitfalls That's not to say that bamboo is a perfect solution. The NRDC points out in its 2019 report that hardwood forests are now being destroyed just to make room for bamboo plantations, so it's important to buy only bamboo products that are FSC-accredited. The fact that most bamboo is imported from Asia adds to its environmental impact, too. Post-Use Bamboo toilet paper is generally 100% biodegradable; it will decompose naturally and break down much faster than regular or recycled varieties, some of which can take several years to fully decompose. Its quick-dissolving nature makes bamboo toilet paper septic-safe and less likely to clog systems than traditional toilet paper. Recycled Toilet Paper NataliaDeriabina / Getty Images Recycled toilet paper is made by soaking paper scraps in warm water, aerating the mixture to remove ink, bleaching and sanitizing it, then pressing and drying it, like with traditional toilet paper. According to the NRDC, recycling paper into bathroom tissue requires less water and energy and creates less air and water pollution than making bathroom tissue from timber; however, consumers should beware of misleading marketing claims and lurking chemicals. BPA Contamination A large portion of post-consumer recycled content has a thermal coating — think: the glossy papers used for receipts, lottery tickets, and shipping labels. Thermal paper contains bisphenol-A, better known as BPA, which has been found in recycled toilet paper. A study that examined BPA levels in paper products noted that dermal absorption of the toxin has minor health consequences compared with exposure through consumption (which has been linked to infertility, increased blood pressure, and more), but the environmental impact is greater. When paper containing BPA is flushed down the toilet, it can disrupt the reproductive systems of aquatic wildlife, resulting in a generational ripple effect that could forever alter ecosystems. Pre-Consumer vs. Post-Consumer Recycled Content "Recycled" has become a vague, misunderstood, and unregulated greenwashing term in the toilet paper industry. The NRDC notes that a product can be branded as 100% recycled even if less than half of it is made of post-consumer recycled content. The rest is "manufactured waste," or pre-consumer recycled content, which, according to the Environmental Protection Agency, comes from "scrap generated after completion of the papermaking process." In other words, pre-consumer recycled content is an unused byproduct of papermaking itself. The EPA recommends bathroom tissue that contains at least 20% to 60% post-consumer recycled content. Beware of Bleaching Toilet paper is bleached not just to make it sparkling white but also to make it softer. Historically, the prevailing bleaching method has involved elemental chlorine, a chemical agent that creates dioxin as a byproduct. This highly toxic, cancer-causing compound can compromise human immune and reproductive systems and is largely responsible for the catastrophic, global collapse of various bird species. The use of elemental chlorine has been mostly phased out, the NRDC says, but toilet papers labeled ECF (elemental chlorine-free) still release elemental chlorine gas into air and water. When shopping for toilet paper of any kind, look for the PCF (processed chlorine-free) label — meaning it's been bleached using less toxic methods — or, better yet, the TCF (totally chlorine-free) label. Which Is Better? Although bamboo is said to be softer and healthier for skin, the NRDC says recycled toilet paper currently has a lower environmental impact. That's because bamboo — wonderfully resilient, self-growing, and low-maintenance as it is — is too often planted on deforested land, because it doesn't promote biodiversity in the way hardwood does, and because it's most often imported from China, the bamboo capital of the world. While the FSC does have a bamboo-centric certification meant to ensure sustainable practices, the legitimacy and effectiveness of said certification has received criticism because bamboo is a grass rather than a tree. The NRDC's "Issue With Tissue" report included a scorecard in which major toilet paper brands were graded based on the percent of pre-consumer and post-consumer recycled content used, FSC certification, and bleaching processes. Every brand that received an A contained about 80% to 100% post-consumer recycled material and used chlorine-free bleaching processes. Top-scorers included Green Forest, Whole Foods Market's 365 Everyday Value, and Royal Paper's Earth First. The 2020 winner was Who Gives A Crap, which uses 95% post-consumer recycled product. Recycled and bamboo toilet paper cost about the same, although both are generally more expensive than toilet papers made from timber. View Article Sources "The Issue with Tissue: How Americans are Flushing Forests Down the Toilet." Natural Resource Defense Council. Bernier, Meghan and Vandenberg, Laura. "Handling of Thermal Paper: Implications for Dermal Exposure to Bisphenol A and Its Alternatives." PLOS ONE, vol. 12, no. 6, 2017, pp. e0178449, doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0178449 Liao, Chunyang and Kannan, Kurunthachalam. "Widespread Occurrence of Bisphenol A in Paper and Paper Products: Implications for Human Exposure." American Chemical Society, vol. 45, no. 21, 2011, pp. 9372-9379, doi:10.1021/es202507f Canesi, Laura and Fabbri, Elena. "Environmental Effects of BPA: Focus on Aquatic Species." Dose-Response, vol. 13, no. 3, 2015, doi:10.1177/1559325815598304 "Definitions, Specifications, and Other Guidance about the Comprehensive Procurement Guideline Program." Environmental Protection Agency. "Analyses of Laboratory and Field Studies of Reproductive Toxicity in Birds Exposed to Dioxin-Like Compounds for Use in Ecological Risk Assessment." Environmental Protection Agency.