What Deep Water Drilling and Nuclear Power Have in Common


Photo via Seeker 401

Put simply, the capacity for something to go very, very wrong as a result of technical mismanagement (or otherwise). Now, there are surely a great number of things that could also fit the bill, but I highlight these for a reason: In the wake of the BP spill, there are numerous calls for ramping up clean energy -- and for many, that means nuclear. You're likely going to hear a lot of appeals for expanding nuclear power as a reaction to the BP spill, as a cleaner power source that doesn't have to be perilously extracted from miles under the sea. Mark Gimein of the Big Money highlights the dilemma posed in a piece called Accidents Will Happen. And he's right -- they will. They do all the time. Here's an excerpt:

you would think that a giant oil-related accident would be another point against fossil fuels and for nuclear, and in some ways it is. In one very important way, however, it is not. The most visceral concern about nuclear power comes down to, "What if something goes wrong?" Deepwater Horizon is a compelling reminder that things go wrong, in unexpected ways, at unexpected times, to catastrophic effect.
As we have seen with the BP spill, governmental regulations aren't always capable of preventing worst-case scenarios from unfolding. Private industry, given the opportunity, will sometimes cut corners to save income. And as we've seen in the past, when improperly managed (Chernobyl) accidents can of course be devastating.

With these facts in mind, it's worth noting that other lesson to be learned from the BP spill: That accidents will happen. (The first is, of course, that fossil fuels are growing scarce, and becoming dangerous to extract, and that we need to turn to other energy sources.)

I'm not arguing that we should discount nuclear power altogether on such grounds (neither is Gimein) -- just that we should be looking at the whole picture, not picking and choosing morals from the BP spill debacle.

More on the BP Gulf Spill
Underwater Robot Accident Causes 100,000s of Gallons of Oil to Gush from BP Spill Source
Judge Strikes Down Obama's Offshore Drilling Ban

Related Content on Treehugger.com