Door Prize Lady Charged "To The Full Extent of the Law"

ghost-bike-toronto-victim photo

Ghost Bike for Un-named victim, Toronto

We were appalled when, after yet another door prize death, a policeman discussed charging the woman who did it and said "If she didn't look, would that be negligence? It's very hard to label that as negligent." In our survey, 75% of the respondents agreed that " The driver broke the law and killed someone and should be charged to the full extent of the law."

Well it turns out, she has been charged, with "Open Vehicle Door Improperly", which carries a maximum punishment, if convicted, of demerit points and an approximate $110 fine.

Is this enough? "The consequences should reflect the severity of the crime," said Yvonne Bambrick, the assistant co-ordinator of the Toronto Cyclists Union. "We do not believe that this charge is adequate in this matter" ::The Star Press release from Police below the fold.


Ghost Bike for Hubert van Tol, Toronto

Toronto Police Service
News Release
Traffic fatality #20/2008, Update, Charge laid
Friday, June 27, 2008 - 3:11 PM
Traffic Services
On Thursday, May 22, 2008, at 1:12 p.m., police responded to a personal injury collision at Eglinton Avenue West/Avenue Road.

It is alleged that:

- a 57-year-old man was cycling east on Eglinton Avenue West, passing a line of parked cars on the south side of the street,

- an occupant of one of the cars, a woman, 43, opened the driver's door,

- the cyclist struck the door, lost control of his bicycle, fell onto the roadway and was struck by a truck.

The cyclist was taken to hospital where he succumbed to his injuries. This is the first cycling fatality of 2008.

Traffic Services, in consultation with the City of Toronto's Prosecutors' Office, have laid a charge of "Open Vehicle Door Improperly" under the Highway Traffic Act.

An information laying out the charge has been filed with Old City Hall Courts.

Constable Wendy Drummond, Public Information, for Sergeant Tim Burrows, Traffic Services

::National Post via ::Biking Toronto

TreeHugger on Bike Safety

Bike Safety Tips From MP Olivia Chow
Freakonomics on Bike Safety
Karl Lagerfeld Isn't Afraid To Look Dorky
Scary Fifties Bloody and Gory Filmstrip on Bike Safety
What Some Drivers Think About Cyclists in Tucson
TreeHugger on the Door Prize:
Collecting the Door Prize : TreeHugger
Survey: Should Drivers Who Give Out The Door Prize Be Charged ...
The Door Prize

TreeHugger on Ghost Bikes

Ghost Bikes: A Memorial to Cyclists
Taking Back the Streets: Cyclist Memorials
Bike Advocate Keeps the Memory of Her Husband Alive

Related Content on