Six Myths About Health During the Holiday Season

by Bonnie Alter, London on 12.18.08
Food & Health

hats in winter photo

TreeHugger loves exposing myths. We have written about energy myths, wind turbine myths and global danger ones. Now here are a few health myths that may surprise you.

l. Wear a Hat to Keep in the Heat
Everyone knows that you wear a hat in winter to keep in the body heat. Right? Wrong. A new study reported in the British Medical Journal claims that keeping one part of the body covered has just as much effect as covering any other. So when it is cold outside, wrap up, but wearing a hat won't make a big difference.

2. Sugar Makes Children Hyper-Active
There is a common belief that parents should cut back on the sugar for the children because it makes them hyper-active. This seems to be a figment of parents' imagination--the study says that tests show that there is no difference in the behaviour of those children that had sugar and those that didn't. This includes sugar from candy, chocolate and natural sources.

poinsettias myths photo

3. Hang-overs are Curable
The third myth is hangovers--there is no cure for hangovers. Never mind the aspirin, bananas, water--the only cure is drinking less.

4. Late Night Snacks are Fattening
Here's a delicious surprise: Late night snacking is not more fattening. It's just a matter of how much and how often you eat, not when.

5. Suicide Rates Jump at Christmas
More suicides over holiday periods? No again; there are fewer before, more afterwards. And surprisingly, the numbers are lower in the winter and higher in the summer.

6. Poinsettias are Poisonous
And lastly, bring on the poinsettias....they are not toxic. An analysis of all the so-called poisoning by the flowers showed that no one died from eating them and more than 96 percent of the cases didn't even need hospital treatment. Guardian


More on Popular Myths

Five Myths Causing Global Harm
Ten Energy Myths Exposed

Follow @TreeHugger on Twitter & get our headlines with @TH_rss!

Comments (14)

These "Scientists" need to have some children of their own. Experienced parents and especially teachers know better. They are simply using the wrong protocol to test the hypothesis.

Reminds me of the one where "Scientists Prove" that the full moon has no effect on human behavior. Ask any ER doc or nurse. Especially ask the check in assistant.

Want a nuclear explosion. Give kids a ton of cheap candy with food dyes on the day following a full moon. Especially good on empty stomach.

jump to top John Laumer says:

Is it really necessary to post this grossly misleading garbage?

jump to top Jaosn Miles says:

Seriously - Is this article from the skeptics dictionary? It is really inaccurate. Please take some common sense and experience into account before publishing something on this site or it diminishes the validity of the entire site.

jump to top heather says:

Well, as for candy and children... if you want to get all anecdotal... I give my nieces candy and they calm down.

It also helps if there's not more than 1 or 2 around. Energy levels seem to rise exponentially when there's more kids around.

jump to top Sara says:

Total bunk, what a worthless article.

jump to top Lee Kembel says:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/7789302.stm

jump to top Anonymous says:

It is a common misconception that the tropical poinsettia is toxic.

The real toxic holiday plant is mistletoe!

It causes acute gastrointestinal problems including stomach pain, and diarrhea along with low pulse.

Don't let the kids, pets, or drunk guests eat it.

jump to top Ginger says:

Epic fail of an article. Loads of water and a large vegetarian cafe breakfast have fixed just about every hangover I've ever had.

jump to top glittalogik [TypeKey Profile Page] says:

Old nurse here and for me during the winter months, since I do keep my house around 64 f or a little less, I can stay warmer, being fully dressed, wearing a hat than wearing a thermal fall jacket. The head gets a lot more blood flowing through it (as seen when someone bleeds profusely via flesh cut/scratch) which allows for more heat to dissipate out of the blood.

I will stick with Mythbusters when it comes to learning if a myth can be Confirmed or Busted.

jump to top Carl says:

What total bullshit!

Come on Treehugger I expect better that this sensationalist garbage.

Shame on you.....

jump to top Anonymous says:

I personally had two estranged relatives that committed suicide right before Christmas.

jump to top Sirerdrick [TypeKey Profile Page] says:

How do you go from "keeping one part of the body covered has just as much effect as covering any other" to saying a hat isn't incredibly important? That's lazy analysis: when it's cold, you're already wearing a shirt, pants and shoes -- so that only leaves a hat and gloves as easy next steps. So, yes, technically, a hat is no MORE important than, say, pants, but it's also no LESS important than, say, pants.

Good research, but one that confirms the "myth," not debunks it.

jump to top DDK says:

The research regarding kids and sugar has been around for years. The first commenter, John Laumer, got it right when he mentioned "cheap candy with food dyes," as one study I remember concluding that red food dye has a hyperactive effect on children.

On the other hand, I agree with DDK that the phrasing of #1 is misleading. Also, I am curious about the late-night snacking myth: Sumo wrestlers, for example, actually eat relatively healthy diets. They may eat more, but I know napping after each meal is part of the regimen. It makes sense that eating right before reducing one's metabolism (e.g. by sleeping) would increase the percentage of calories fully obtained from the food.

jump to top Sheepguy42 [TypeKey Profile Page] says:

LOL. No matter the forum you will run into those, who will apply their own limited data from their own limited world, to judge others. Heck I may have done just that myself here. ;)

jump to top kansan says:

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)