Video of Endangered Beluga Whales Playing

by Michael Graham Richard, Ottawa, Canada on 10.22.08
Travel & Nature

Comments (5)

Not to harsh your post, but.......

Whales are mammals, I'll grant you that.
But 'playing'??

The anthropomorphic description of animals is unscientific and I frankly believe it demeans real humans - humans that may need help, suffer and in some cases die from lack of food, resources or medicine.

I'm not so much against Save the Whales, as for Save the Humans......

(For those in Rio Linda
Adjective
ascribing human form or attributes to a being or thing not human, esp. to a deity.
resembling or made to resemble a human form: an anthropomorphic carving.)

jump to top Don says:

"Whales are mammals, I'll grant you that.
But 'playing'??

The anthropomorphic description of animals is unscientific and I frankly believe it demeans real humans - humans that may need help, suffer and in some cases die from lack of food, resources or medicine."

You are the unscientific one, here. Anyone who knows anything about social animals, especially mammals, know that they really do play (for fun, to learn skills, and to maintain relationships).

jump to top Anonymous says:

I agree with Don,

Anonymous is totally wrong; it's just common sense. What are these whales accomplishing by blowing bubble rings and twirling in circles? It's obviously just social interaction, or play.

Apart from that, I'm all for saving the humans. But I don't see how it is necessarily more important to save humans than whales. If all of the whales on this planet die, then humans won't be far behind.

We should save the humans AND the whales. In fact, in the long run you save both or you save neither.

jump to top joeB says:

"The anthropomorphic description of animals is unscientific..."

Try telling that to Jane Goodall... She was initially dismissed in such high-handed fashion but she has shown the world that it is human arrogance that presumes that only Homo sapiens are capable of emotion, fun and so on. The concept of “anthropomorphism" should be understood as nothing more than an extension of racism and defence of human domination over nature.

Whether it is right to keep whales in captivity is another issue. At least, however, they are not swimming in a toxic stew of effluent.

jump to top Anonymous says:

I'm more concerned whether this video actually shows the whales having fun. It seems they are being used for exhibition more than just free play.

jump to top Anna says:

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)




th top picks