Home Delivery: The Reviews Are In
by Lloyd Alter, Toronto on 07.21.08

Photo from James Wagner
We so want to see Home Delivery, the exhibition of prefab at the Museum of Modern Art. Since we haven't got there yet, we are reading the reviews:
Nicolai Ouroussoff in the New York Times: “Home Delivery: Fabricating the Modern Dwelling,” is a delightful surprise.....The effect is startling: expressions of a suburban utopian world surrounded by Midtown’s looming skyscrapers."
Justin Davidson in New York Magazine: "sporadically exciting but ultimately diffuse."
Art Critic James Wagner on JamesWagner.com:
The show is fascinating, at least as much for a historical survey as for a review of the latest innovations. ...But I confess to one serious misgiving about the show.
In a world whose population is exploding, whose natural environment is threatened and whose resources are diminishing (including especially the resources which have supported cheap transportation of all forms), it would seem to me that if a modern museum's show about architecture is focused almost entirely on free-standing private dwelling units, regardless of all the sexy bits about computer design, pre- or modularly-fabricated structures, and revolutionary ecological breakthroughs, it is at least half-dead in the water already and unlikely to be remembered as a landmark achievement by any future generation...
..the [population] projection for 2050 is for close to ten billion. If we haven't learned to live in sophisticated multiple dwellings by then, those who have somehow managed to survive are likely to be sheltering inside mud huts. ::James Wagner
The Five Prefabs in TreeHugger
First Pix of Home Delivery Prefabs in New York
System3 House Installed at MoMA Home Delivery Exhibition
Home Delivery: Wrapping It Up With The Cellophane House
Home Delivery: Digitally Fabricated Housing
BURST*008: More Prefab at MoMA's Home Delivery Exhibition
Home Delivery: The Micro Compact Home Comes To America
More on Home Delivery
Five Modern Prefabs Coming to the MOMA
Photo Essay of Home Delivery Houses in New York Times :





















"it would seem to me that if a modern museum's show about architecture is focused almost entirely on free-standing private dwelling units, regardless of all the sexy bits about computer design, pre- or modularly-fabricated structures, and revolutionary ecological breakthroughs, it is at least half-dead in the water already and unlikely to be remembered as a landmark achievement by any future generation..."
this statement reminds me of another:
"you have to crawl before you can walk"
you can just start at the beginning with a final goal in mind and bang, there it is. if these were meant to be the new way of life they wouldnt be featured in a museum, you would see them in you neighborhood.
Wagner is dead on.
This show is provocative in a way it isn't meant to
in the sense that it is displaying luxury micro homes that don't either fit the needs or possibilities of the hundreds of thousands of people that every week move into shantytowns across the globe or even the economical and cultural elite it displays itself to.
The target group seem to be the architects themselves, always eager to be teased by another formal and constructive exercise. But this isn't the time for the architectural follies it is time for solving problems using architecture without vanity but as a fundamental a service to humanity like engineering and agriculture.
The curators of the exhibition are either complacent and\or oblivious to the blaring warnings about the problems of our built environment and find themselves dazzled by irrelevance and hoping the world follows into this kind of built escapism.
It completely disregards the transformative, provocative and pedagogical function of art in general...
Classy. Criticize it for what it isn't and not solving all of the world's problems at once.
It'll be interesting to see how this compare to the modernist house show they had about fifty years ago in the garden.
Some people will always live in single family detached houses. Those should be as good as they can be. Other housing types should get their day in the sun, too, and maybe more exposure and attention when they deserve it. Maybe that question should be put to MoMa's director.