most popular: Sex in Small Cars?


most popular:
Killer Smog Clouds


th comments
Willy Bio said: "Well, Mr. Smarty, by your own admission, you already have. So please, enlighten us...." [read]

Cinthesooner said: "I also like anything by Marion Nestle- especially "What to Eat" and "Food Politics". If you ever get a chance to see her speak- please do- she is ..." [read]

Anthony said: ""...bettered only by Norway's legendary farmed salmon, where .95 kilos of food get a kilo of flesh." Um... unless they eat a lot of fatty f..." [read]

Eric Dewhirst said: "@ Bob and others - Throwing stones at Wal-Mart is like blaming your parents - it get's you nowhere. I am sure that Wal-Mart is fully aware that th..." [read]

mysoultokeep said: "Frankly, this just seems like one more story of one more industry faltering because it's a house of cards held together by subsidies and tax breaks..." [read]

The French Rabbit Strike Again- TH Interviews Jean Charles Boisset about the wine industry

by Bonnie Hulkower, New York, New York on 06.13.08
Food & Health

Jean%20Charles%20Boisset%27s%20Aluminum%20Blue%20Dot%20Beaujolais.jpg

TH did a story about the French Rabbit a few years ago, and now Jean Charles is back preaching his innovative wine packaging to oenophiles and the masses. He is fully aware that some people in the wine industry may think he is an extraterrestrial. Even some previous TH readers said "I'll pass and stick with glass". But, certainly not Tom who is opening a wine bar in New York City.

Jean-Charles-Boisset-vineyard-photo.jpg

Treehugger(TH): What got you started in the whole organic, sustainable movement?
Jean Charles Boisset (JCB): My grandparents were great teachers who believed in the lunar cycles, in a sense of space and movement, as I do. Which is why biodynamic fits so well with me. 507 is not a pair of jeans! All of my vineyards are eco-certified organic. Some are fully biodynamic, others are moving that way. My vineyards were certified by the late 1990's. I really pushed that part of the movement.

TH: Isn't it challenging financially to go green?
JCB: It is always challenging when you want to do something differently. Farming organically/biodynamically was initially a big constraint, but then it just inspired me to take things to the next level—to think about my whole production cycle. I now think about everything—my soap, my electricity consumption. I changed the voltage in my cellars, I believe electricity affects wine. I spent more than $3 million on water treatment. I started to think about organic inks on the label, and organic glues, recycled cartons, lighter glass, less cork. In our offices, we have water fountains, but paper cups are interdit!

TH: What made you focus on the low end of the market? It seems to me most vintners try to focus on the high end.
JCB: Typically 7 out of 10 wine bottles cost less than $12. Most wines are drunk within 30 minutes of purchase. For these less expensive wines, the cost of packaging is the "bulk" of the cost. We need to change this practice. We need to do it to protect the climate, but we also need to do it to add value for the customer/retailer. Convenience, ecology, and value are a trifecta. Americans shouldn't complain, in France, gas is $8/gallon.

TH: In the past you pushed the “French rabbit,” a milk carton like “tetrapack” packaging with "ears". What’s up your sleeve now?
JCB: The French rabbit allowed us to save 24 trips to the winery for trucks delivering glass bottles, that's a lot of carbon saved. You can also put 2x as much wine in the French rabbit, I wish I had invented the tetrapack! One of the pluses of the tetrapak is you can hide your alcohol consumption from nosy neighbors. In France, you are charged by the amount of garbage you have, which is an incentive to create less waste. There are 175 "green policemen" who check if people, especially restaurants are recycling.
My next release is an aluminum container for wine. It is great especially for Beaujolais. Many people drink it at room temperature, but it is lovely to drink it slightly chilled, it is charming. These aluminum containers have a Blue Dot technology that changes to blue when the wine is chilled. That way you know when the wine is ready to drink. It could take 30 minutes or more to cool a glass bottle of wine, with the aluminum it only takes 10 minutes. This is launching in NYC in the next few weeks. It has already launched on the West coast. Another benefit is you can't break it.

TH: It still seems odd to me to drink wine out of a carton or aluminum, how is it received?
JCB: I like that I am bringing in people who may not normally drink wine. Some people who picnic or camp are now telling me how easy and enjoyable it is to bring wine on these outings. I believe that education leads to excitement, which leads to refinement. My 17 year-old nephew wanted to go to a party in France, and he asked if he could take the aluminum bottles of wine to impress the girls. It is a novelty item. It invokes excitement.

TH: How do you avoid the wine having a metallic taste?
JCB: We conducted many, many tests. We coat the aluminum with epoxy, like the vats used for fermentation. With the epoxy you can't taste it.
The nature of the wine business is not innovation. 3500 years ago they drank wine out of goat skin. In Greek times, they drank out of amphoras. Then in Roman times they drank out of wood. It is crazy to me that people have been drinking wine out of the glass, which is an industry that hasn't seen innovation since the Italian Renaissance. We need to change for the environment and for practicality. I come from Dijon, France, where the mustard container has evolved—so must the wine container. We need different containers to suit different wines and needs. Nice corks are appropriate for nice wines.

TH: So are you trying to democratize drinking wine? Do you drink cheap wine?
JCB: I don't just drink expensive wine. Well, (laughs) I rarely drink wine below $8 a bottle. But still, to love wine, you must be open to drinking all kinds of wine.
With all these efforts, I want to create a shift in the wine world, first, to organic/biodynamic, and then to more sustainable packaging. I'm not sure what the third phase will be.

TH: Perhaps it will be adapting to the climate change we have already created and adjusting our wine growing regions and seasons.
JCB: Yes, perhaps. In 2003, they harvested in August! I believe in listening to nature. I'm against an 8-5 schedule. I'm against heavy equipment that kills the roots of the vines. My vineyards in Burgundy were planed 11 centuries ago. I have a responsibility to the past, to not go for a quick fix. Yes, what I am doing with packaging is ballsy; French wines are based on tradition. I'm used to getting rejected. But good things take time.

TH: Like wine?
JCB: Yes, like wine.

More TH on Wine
Wine Carbon Study Says East Coasters Should Drink French
French Rabbit-Savor the Wine, Save the Planet
biodynamic">Organic and Biodynamic Wines

Comments (8)

Sorry, but these new containers just don't cut it. Tetrapaks are layered paper, foil and plastic and are hardly all that recyclable. Aluminum is no better. One-third of the average cost of aluminum is for the energy required to make it.

Glass, although heavy, can be repeatedly recycled and, if put in a landfill, completely inert. The transportation issues can be partially solved by bulk shipping to local bottling plants. Maybe not too practical for small wineries but a no-brainer for foreign imports.

jump to top Brad says:

I wouldn't let a good wine with potential stored in epoxy for years.

Already some bottles with cork defects can disappoint gourmets. Glass has a nice property : there's nearly no chemical reactions with the wine even over a century. My gut-feeling and initial search on epoxy reactions both make me think that using it to store a product as complex as wine (which taste comes from a delicate balance amongst myriads of chemical components) is not a bright idea.

There are eco-advantages to glass bottles too : they are already widely recycled.
There's even 2 ways of recycling them :
- bringing them back to stores for later reuse (the only way you should do it but it's an imperfect world),
- melting them (less eco-friendly but at least only consumes energy and doesn't leave more pollution than the energy source produces).

For young wines with no aging potential designed to be drinked early, epoxy may be ok, but that's not the kind of wine I drink... I'll pass.

In the end, I'd welcome the opportunity to test an old bottle (at least a 7 years Pessac-Léognan, Beaujolais is mostly a bad joke of French people to the rest of the world) but I won't bet on it and would even fear for my health...

PS : I'm French :-)

jump to top Lionel Bouton says:

Dear God, where to start. Oh, I know. How about we start with the article I wrote on this specific, horrible subject. It can be found at
http://thetyee.ca/Views/2008/03/11/OldBottles/

The tetra-paks he shills are specifically addressed in that article, as are the benefits of refilling. The data on refills can be found here.
http://lookleap.com/books.google.com/a7/look

Finally, let's note that the epoxy lining typically used on aluminum containers contains BPA, which is not getting much love right now.

jump to top Ruben says:

epoxy tho has bisphenol a,

i got a better idea. have all wine bottles made out of only 1 color, then instead of recycling them just have them sent back to the wine bottlers, have them sterilized and then reused.

jump to top not a lemming says:

You are my new hero.

jump to top Peter Smee says:

And what, pray tell, is the epoxy liner made from? BPA? Phthalates? What? I'd have to know that before I drank the wine.

That said, if there are only organic ingredients in the packaging, which there should be for organically certified or biodynamic wine, I applaud his innovation. The world needs more innovators. And more organic wine.

Shine On,
Lill

jump to top Lill Hawkins says:

After reading this interview and the comments I ran out and found some French Rabbit at the grocery to see what all the fuss was about. It's good wine.

California wineries are starting to pack theirs the same way.

jump to top windsor says:

What's wrong with wine in a box? You get the equivalent of four bottles of wine in a lightweight, recyclable container that keeps it fresh for weeks since no air gets into the inner plastic bag.

Seems like the perfect solution for everyday table wine, no?

jump to top Max Pinton says:

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

th ads
th top picks
th ads