most popular:
2008 Holiday Gift Guides



most popular: Hot Home Wind Turbines


most popular:
$19k Electric Car in US


th comments
Yoav Binyamini said: ""The target price of 20 to 25 thousand euros (US $27 - 34 thousand) puts the Will in the class of affordable electric vehicles" Why not 'Ta..." [read]

Robert McGibbon said: "It's more accurate to say that it runs on lemmons AND zinc. The zinc anode gets depleted. A non renewable resource so to speak...." [read]

Rod Richardson said: "Yes but... the problem with many of the major proposal on the table or in the platform is that they are either expensive (at a time the budget is s..." [read]

Rod Richardson said: "Yes but... the problem with many of the major proposal on the table or in the platform is that they are either expensive (at a time the budget is s..." [read]

barry said: "Flying seattle to galapagos dumps 12,000 pounds of greenhouse gases into our future...per person. There is no way anyone can do that level of clima..." [read]

I Am A Plastic Bag and Proud Of It

by Lloyd Alter, Toronto on 07.30.07
Culture & Celebrity

i_am_main.jpg

Seeking authentic in a knock-off world? Facts not fashion? Then don’t miss out on this 100% recyclable and reusable plastic bag. That’s right! Looking for a practical solution to a greener globe? This is the real deal…

There should be word for this; it isn't astroturfing, which is "public relations campaigns in politics and advertising that seek to create the impression of being spontaneous, grassroots behavior." The Progressive Bag Alliance makes no pretense about being anything but a group of plastic bag manufacturers. We suppose that there must be a Buggy Whip Alliance out there as well, there is an association to preserve every dying industry. They are selling the bags on eBay, along with a pile of truths they call myths. Read their last gasp of PR folly at ::Progressive Bag Alliance via ::New Consumer

Comments (5)

This is yet another example of how Treehugger is promoting a myopic view of sustainability. You guys must think you have it all figured out and are expert environmentalists because you seem to keep being very one sided regarding your coverage.

Instead of focusing on behavior you're only looking at the objects you no longer value. Plastic bags do use less energy in manufacturing than paper, and there is a misconception that paper is better than plastic. Why not stop chopping down trees to make paper bags? How did you get to the point of preferring paper over plastic? It became a mainstream idea, and you don't have the facts to understand why you think this way.

So, lets give the plastic bag industry a break if they are trying to influence people who are not going to carry their canvas mesh bags to the grocery stores, but are hoping customers dead set on using plastic bags will value the idea of at least recycling them!

Same thing is happening with the light bulb situation. The mercury that is in the lamp and the ballasts is far more dangerous in the near term than the energy savings in their operation. They also require a ton more energy to manufacture, but you seem okay with China using their coal-fired power plants to make these energy-sipping puppies for you to have clean air in the USA? You're missing the big picture.

jump to top Eric says:

Eric, on what do you base your claim that plastic bags use less energy in manufacturing than paper? What about other externalities of manufacturing, like pollution and the infrastructure necessary to supply petroleum products to the bag manufacturers?

As for recycling, what can you recycle a plastic bag into? How much energy is used in that recycling, vs. making a new bag? What types of pollution is created?

Third, it seems like the target of this message (the one printed on the bag) is not that plastic disposable bags are better than paper, but that they are better than a reusable bag, which is completely unfounded. You can use a string bag an innumerable number of times, and you can repair it.

jump to top Jim says:

Just wanted to agree with Eric about the hypocricy of the enviornmental movement. I marched in the original Earth day demonstration while in high school. Things seemed to be going better in the 1970's in terms of personal responsibility (even though we were so ignorant of the big picture environmental damage.)
Ex: we learned this stuff:
1. reusuable bags are good
2. small cars- less gas (due to cost mostly)-
also gas rationing good- able to fill up car gas every other day (odd/even license plate encourged people to buy fuel effiecient cars.
3. solar energy panel credits- Reagan cut them. You could use it to heat your hot water. I remember in CO it was used to power outhouses above the tree line.
4. PUT A BRICK IN YOUR TOILET to save on water consumption. SHOWER WITH A FRIEND, yes those were the days.
5. Plant trees, go to 'fern bars', eat locally produced foods
6. Don't buy alot of new clothes, wear the same pair of pants a few times. Avoid dry cleaning.
7. Shop at Goodwill. It takes alot of energy to make clothing, plus shipping, and don't forget the slave labor.

Suprising back then- curbside recycling almost unheard of.

Anyway, even ' we old hippies'' had forgotten some lessons, but are remembering and learning others. Get a brick, put it in your toliet, don't buy so many clothes, xeroscape yards and buy energy efficent cars. At least its a start.
-Carol

jump to top Carol Morter says:

My municipality doesn't accept plastic bags as part of normal recycling.

Eric, proof? For anything you say?

Assuming both the bags are made in the same place, of resources shipped from the same distance, brought to the same store, and recycled into new bags (if possabIe, I wonder if plastic has to be downcycled) until the origional material is all trashed, which REALLY uses more energy?

The hysteria over mercury seems to be absent of genuine science. Even if both bulbs go to the landfill, CFLs release less mercury than incandescents.

jump to top Anonymous says:

I like Eric, I bet he's an ally of the petroleum industry. What's wrong with plastic bags and the monsters they create when they accumulate?? Bag Monsters aren't so bad, you know... I'm a family monster with millions of little Bag Monster spawn to worry about. Some of them live under kitchen sinks, but most of them live in the bay and ocean. Search for my Bag Monster blog to learn more about how we're being oppressed world wide. All these bag bans are supposedly because we make an expensive mess, cause "environmental damage," and because a few of us were eaten by marine animals... Don't they know better than to eat Bag Monsters?

jump to top Bag Monster says:

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

th ads
th top picks
th ads