most popular: Bike Tree Protects Bikes


most popular: Bears Swarm Playground


most popular: Help Protect Great Tits

th comments
Chris said: "OK but does this actually reduce the amount of carbon spewed into the atmosphere. That's the only real value I care about...." [read]

907ValleyTrash said: "In Alaska, Governor Palin recently proposed that, since the state is making bank off the oil companies these days (a percentage of profits, basical..." [read]

wiseman said: "I agree. Solar Thermal is just another part of a big mix of solutions. There are no magic bullets and it's silly to think there might be. Solar The..." [read]

Mark Kiernan said: "My next car!!!..." [read]

Jason said: "Maybe this has already been added but the right small car has a lot of space. I am partial to VW, but my golf seats 5 (I am 6ft 3in and fit in the..." [read]

Attack Of The Mutant Artificial Trees

by John Laumer, Philadelphia on 12. 3.06
Business & Politics

attack_of_the_mutant.jpg

The National Christmas Tree Growers Association is offering a free download of "Attack of The Mutant Articificial Trees," a game that seems to have left the plastic tree sellers feeling 'lost in the toilet brush woods' (according the the NCTGA, the company that invented the mutant ones originally made toilet brushes). So, when that little voice in your head asks 'do you want a real tree or do you want a fake one'...this is reminding us of a visit to the grocery store and hearing the 'paper or plastic' voice... the Association's website has a rundown of reasons to go with the real thing. Among the best cited: real trees are mostly grown in North America, while the fake ones largely are shipped from China; and, the vinyl often used in fake trees commonly includes a great deal of inorganic lead as a "stabilizer" and/or fire proofing agent, requiring a Prop 65 warning label in California. We suggest you check the 'fire proof' test shots on the website. Finally, while Christmas Tree farms may be often poor on the biodiversity scale, we should not forget that their product can be recycled.

Comments (15)

How about getting a living X-mas tree and planting it after you're done with it? Or decorate a large houseplant, like a ficus or norfolk pine that you keep in the house all year long? That's what my family does.

If you do get a large living tree and aren't able to plant it yourself, how about asking your local scouts or 4H group to organize a live tree collection and planting on some public land?

jump to top Turil says:

Real Tree or Fake? This is a question I had recently from a client of mine and was surprised to find that real was the way to go.

I have a question, what if you are allergic to trees? We have a fake tree that we bought years ago because we are allergic to the real thing in our house. Other than the "Don't have a tree" or "Have a tree outside" answer, does anyone know of a GREEN fake tree out there?
=== author's response follows ===
Pine pollen or other trapped pollens as well as mold may cause allergic response. Setting up and decorating diserses these into your home. If weather permits, suggest hosing the tree down first with a strong spray, possibly even a power sprayer (no soaps though). Let it dry well before you bring inside. Anyone else tried this?

Anyone know if pinene/terpene compound vapors can actually cause allergic response (washing would not affect these).

jump to top Wayne Green says:

I have a used, hand me down fake tree. It was going to be thrown out, but I saved it and 12 years later I still use it.

I like the saved from a landfill idea because then I don't have to worry about a live tree, or where to put it when I am done.

The potted trees/shrubs tend to be grown the standard agricultural way (read: tons of chemical pesticides and fertilizers).

Buy organic!
Unfortunately, there are only a handful of organic "christmas tree" growers in the USofA, none of which seem to sell outside their location in the Eastern part of USofA.

However, one may still buy a permit and cut his/her own on National Forest and/or BLM land across the USofA for usually less than $10.

My area has stopped with the permits because of years of drought, so my family has settled on a potted rosemary plant. We will soon also purchase an organic wreath from either organicbouquet.com or a vendor on localharvest.org to give our house the familiar pine smell and sight that my midwestern blood craves every winter.

jump to top consumer_q says:

We bought a Leyland Cypress this year which would seem to be a bit eco-friendlier since they grow so darn fast and thus require less land to supply X number of trees.

Also, since these aren't "pine" trees, I haven't had nearly the allergy issues I have with normal live trees. Much more beautiful and cheaper too.

jump to top Leyland Cypress says:

someone I know once used a green miniskirt tacked to the wall in place of a tree.

jump to top sam says:

Is there an artificial tree that is made from recycled products? Or an artificial that is eco-friendly? Thanks!

jump to top will says:

Real trees make my family sick over the holidays (not me, though), so we have to use a fake tree.

jump to top Anonymous says:

I have used fake trees my entire life. Because of allergies, pets and pine mess. I have had the same fake tree for 12+ years and my family used the same one for 20 years before passing it on to someone else who still uses it.

jump to top Cheri says:

Nothing beats a real tree. Get a live one in a pot and use it for many years. Mine, I'll use for the sixth year. Don't forget to shape it every now and then. Organic is best.

jump to top Ed says:

LMAO! Allergic to trees... what will people think of next?

jump to top brennan says:

It's time to think around the tree. The tradition of using a real tree harks to the days when there were fewer people and more trees. When I was growing up, we went out and cut our own tree off our farm. A scraggly, Charlie-Brownish type cedar, that nonetheless filled the bill in a simpler, less perfect time. Now trees are grown to be perfect and shipped thousands of miles. It's insane.

Or tons of toxic chemicals used to make fake trees still shipped thousands of miles- all in the quest of capturing an old time era in a more perfect form. In my less green days, my famiy purchased a fake tree. We are still using it 15 years later.

When I replace it, it's going to be some organic material,tree-shaped form. I saw a wonderful tree of that type in a Christmas show recently and thought "why the heck can't we all do that". The woman with the green miniskirt on the wall came close. That's where we all have to go.

jump to top kate Huppell says:

This Christmas my fiancee decorated the Norfolk Island pine that I have been growing for about ten years. It looks nice and does quite well indoors.

I also really like the rosemary idea. Maybe I'll buy one this year to add to my collection of plants. I suspect a rosemary would do best indoors if it is misted frequently to prevent it drying out.

jump to top Jared says:

Then there is the Freegan way.
Go to the local tree place and ask for some of the branches that have been cut off the bottoms of sold trees.

Our grab a discarded tree right after Christmas.

jump to top Anonymous says:

My FFA chapter was selling chritmas trees this holiday season and nine out of ten people had fake trees. the reason was it was easier and cheaper in the long run. I like real trees i have gone through six potted trees. each year we plant them in our yard as a reminder of the past years

jump to top tawnie says:

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

th ads
th top picks
th ads