most popular:
2008 Holiday Gift Guides



most popular: Hot Home Wind Turbines


most popular:
$19k Electric Car in US


th comments
Tim P. said: ""Cava is the Spanish equivalent of champagne, but much tastier." Says who? Just because it's Spanish and you're writing from Barcelona?..." [read]

said: "if the government or state could give incentives or just give it's residents a sub $10,000 windmill to charge the car then that would solve the pow..." [read]

kara said: "hello David - these are not sponsored ads. they are offered exclusively for our TH readers... there is no cost involved. thank you, Kara..." [read]

Dan said: "This story is great, good luck to him! I would love to do something like this, however I do wonder if he aware that there are infact 7 continents n..." [read]

Rebecca said: "In addition to expanding the grid capabilities to help in distribution of wind energy resources, perhaps a more widely distributed network of energ..." [read]

Shimotani Pellet Stoves that Look Good

by Lloyd Alter, Toronto on 11.20.06
Science & Technology (alternative energy)

shimotani_concord_05_stove.jpg

As Justin and Collin point out, pellet stoves are hot. Unfortunately in North America they are also ugly, looking like olde-fashioned wood stoves that would fit in grandma's house but not in any self-respecting modernist's. In Japan, Satoshi Seki designed this modern and colourful unit for Shimotani. Now why can't North American manufacturers do this? ::Shimotani via ::Mocoloco

shimotani_wood_stove.jpg

Read also this article from Asahi.com.

Comments (8)

To me personally, this design may look good for few months perhaps. In long term, something more classic will have a stronger appeal. In USSR similar looking wood stoves were made and boy where they ugly after a while!

jump to top Indrek says:

That looks good? To eaches own.

jump to top Anonymous says:

If you arre looking to buy a pellet stove, first check out used ones. A lot of people who bought them aren't happy with their purchase, so you can often find them on Craigslist and similar on-line bulletin board classifieds.

I sold mine that way, and there were two others for sale at the same time. These things take a lot of maintenance, espeically with the iffy quality pellets that are around. I bought half a ton of pellets that were crap.

Like the comment above, these stoves need constant attention; the burners need cleaning and ash removed (this is a much bigger problem with certain pellets). Also, depending on your stove, you may experience feeding jams, especially if there are a lot of broken pellets. Also beware, if you are looking for emergency heat during a black out, be sure your stove has a battery backup that self charges, and will run for at least 24 hours.

jump to top Anonymous says:

"looking like olde-fashioned wood stoves that would fit in grandma's house but not in any self-respecting modernist's."

Well, you can keep your Crayola pellet stove, I'll take grandma's stove styling any day. Remember Avacado Green and Burnt Orange from the 70's? Yeah, your Sunshine Orange or Happy Face Yellow stove will look pretty dumb in 20 years, too. Better to stick with basic black (or white) for long-lasting and expensive appliances such as this.

I'll also take a wood stove over pellet. Buying pellets gets you the same problem as buying oranges from Florida or cranberries from New Jersey - lots of fuel and $ just to ship it. And lots of energy to make them, too. When demand gets too high the manufacturers end up making sawdust just to make pellets, instead of just using up sawmill leftovers which is supposedly their big benefit. Better to get hardwood locally with the minimal processing necessary to make it usable. I get most of my wood free! Wood doesn't run out like pellets did last year, either. Maintenance is less than a pellet stove, and it doesn't need electricity. Pellet stoves have their usefulness in cities, but not for the majority of the market I think.

jump to top Doug [TypeKey Profile Page] says:

Pellet stoves have their usefulness in cities, but not for the majority of the market I think.

Most of the world's population lives in urban settings. Same for the US (about 80% or more).

jump to top Anonymous says:

You have your numbers backwards. In the US only around 10% of the population lives in urban settings. 50% live in suburban settings, and 40% live in rural settings. A chart in the middle of this slide show supports my rough estimates:

http://sedac.ciesin.columbia.edu/urban_rs/PozziSmall2002_Istanbul.ppt

jump to top Doug [TypeKey Profile Page] says:

I found a full discussion of the graph in that slide show, and here are their actual numbers: "This demographic
classification would place 71% of Americans in suburban
areas, 25% in rural areas and 3% in urban areas in 1990."

http://www.ciesin.columbia.edu/pdf/IEEE_PozziSmall2001.pdf

So my original postulation stands. 97% of the US population lives in non-urban settings where modern EPA-certified wood stoves are a more sustainable solution than pellet stoves.

jump to top Doug [TypeKey Profile Page] says:

RE: Shimotani Pellet Stoves:

Your question:

"Now why can't North American manufacturers do this?

Has been answered:

Snoqualmie Stove Works unveils award winning design...

http://snqstoves.com

Regards

Geoffrey Johnson
Snoqualmie Stoves
R&D

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

th ads
th top picks
th ads