most popular: Sex in Small Cars?


most popular:
Killer Smog Clouds


th comments
Raiyn said: "Willie, so easily upset. It just so happens that my local steel recycler accepts bike chains as does the county. The county magnetically sep..." [read]

Outdoor videos said: "Wow, what a cool story. I really appreciate your passion for making sure people have an open-minded approach to confronting the dangers our planet ..." [read]

Raiyn said: "Typical, no attempted murder or even manslaughter charges. He backed into him, that shows premeditation...." [read]

Patrick said: "It's rather distressing that an article about the search for a sustainable lunch kit includes not just shopping, but shopping for $30 "super-cute H..." [read]

Katherine Isham said: "As a side note, the "meat is an necessary part" argument is probably in reference to vitamin b12. You can actually get vitamin b12 if you're a lact..." [read]

Bottled Water: What a Waste

by Lloyd Alter, Toronto on 02. 8.06
TH Exclusives (un-treehugger)

petbottles.jpg 1.5 million barrels of oil in the US alone are used to make water bottles from polyethylene terephthalate, 86% of which are landfilled or incinerated. Often it is shipped long distances, like the 1.4 million bottles of Finnish tap water sent 4,300 kilometers (2,700 miles) to Saudi Arabia, or the popular Fiji water found in the US and Canada. ''Even in areas where tap water is safe to drink, demand for bottled water is increasing--producing unnecessary garbage and consuming vast quantities of energy,'' said researcher Emily Arnold. ''Although in the industrial world bottled water is often no healthier than tap water, it can cost up to 10,000 times more.'' Tap water comes to us through an energy-efficient infrastructure whereas bottled water must be transported long distances--and nearly one-fourth of it across national borders--by boat, train, airplane, and truck. This ''involves burning massive quantities of fossil fuels,'' Arnold said. Its time to buy a Nalgene and refill it rather than tossing empties. ::Common Dreams via ::Groovy Green

Comments (29)

We just got a reverse osmosis system and immediately noticed how many fewer bottles we have to collect to recycle.

jump to top Zol Hooper says:

but wait!

1) if everyone starts filtering their own water what will they use to make my new fuzzy patagonia polar fleece jacket??

2) aside from HDPE, PET is one of the only other plastics being recycled. So um, what will we do with all thes recycling faciclities and green boxes??

(dood-- totally tongue in cheek here, ok?)

jump to top EarthChange [TypeKey Profile Page] says:

I think this article points out some facts that are completely overlooked when trying to remove our reliance on oil - plastics. OK, so plastics are recyclable but how many people are actually recycling? My mother-in-law almost threw out some Poland Springs bottles the other day because they were only redeemable in Maine until I reminded her of our recycling box.

We can now make plastics from corn starch - PLA. While this article states that PLA and corn crops still have a degree of environmental waste, I wonder what the comparison is between creating plastic from petroleum vs PLA.

Are there other alternatives to producing plastic? I wonder what effect the bottled water lobby has on obfuscating the safeness of tap water in various cities vs bottled water.

jump to top B.K. DeLong [TypeKey Profile Page] says:

While we've been told that Lexan bottles (what most people think of when you say the brand name "Nalgene") are safe, there is evidence that they are as bad as or worse than many other plastics, due to Lexan leaching toxic materials.

According to a Grist column, the #2 plastic bottles are the least dangerous if you want a reusable water bottle.

jump to top Turil [TypeKey Profile Page] says:

Mason jars, mason jars. If you're not traveling or risking breaking it for some reason, this is the way to go. And, at least in the South (US), you'll get lots of people asking you about your moonshine.

jump to top CF says:

Turil, you beat me to the punch.

The safest durable drinking container (someone correct me if I am wrong) is Stainless Steel.

jump to top Lil Hugger says:

I use glass bottles from voss to bottle my water I've always been pretty bothered by the plastics bottle especially because they end up laying around everywhere no one cares what happens to them

jump to top Mike [TypeKey Profile Page] says:

I like the mason jar idea ;)

It would certainly be a sight to see in a college classroom.

jump to top MGR [TypeKey Profile Page] says:

No one seems to be aware of the social danger that buying bottled water supports privatization of this natural resource, and that if the trend keeps going in this direction there will be a day when we'll be at the mercy of a few corporations controling all aspects of society using the leverage power that we are now giving away just for the convinience that represents. Let's not be lazy, raise awareness, demand from authoritys the proper treatment and distribution of potable water and used water, minimize usage, use enviroment friendly products. Water access is not only a human right but is also a universal right for all especies. Is not to much to ask to change our "modern way of life" of "if I want it, I must have it now", be more humble. There has been billions of humans before now, and there should be billions after; what make us think that our most insignificant desires must be satisfied nomatter the cost. This is a selfish phase of human history we are living in and it is up to us to end it.
Everybody should start from this philosophical premise:
"THERE IS NOT SUCH A THING AS GARBAGE". Think it over.

jump to top Alvaro Candela-Najera says:

I thought you would like this article..

Cheers,
Jeanine

jump to top Bob Chew says:

Sometime back, Panama (capital of the Republic of Panama, not the Florida City) used to have one of the purest tap waters of the world, today, the bottled water industries, before unheard of, are now making lot of bucks out of telling the public that "theirs is better".
This is the cost of lazy goverments and our idiocy for shiny things; whereas we should demand-fight for our rights: quality access to a public resource, we prefer to pay 3X to adopt wasting behavior.

jump to top Yanuly Sanson says:

Yeah, I use mason jars for drinking as well as wine glasses (with a cork stopper). I live in idaho and I have people asking me at work if I need all the breaks for my moonshine too. :) The wine bottle gets some looks and comments too.

I also use quart, pint, and half pint jars for leftovers in the fridge, cause I like to avoid plastics as much as possible.

jump to top Jason says:

http://www.polarisinstitute.org/pubs/pubs_inside_the_bottle.html

The Polaris Institue has put out an interesting looking publication about the bottled water industry called "Inside the Bottle" which can be ordered through their website.

jump to top ecogal [TypeKey Profile Page] says:

hey im a student studying sustainable design and need to know some hard facts about water, also i need to know how domestic reed bed systems work? if anyone could volunteer some information or point me where to look, i would be very grateful.
thank you

jump to top William Allen says:

I agree, bottled water is a ridiculous waste. You are basically buying someone else's tap water. Get a carbon filter like Brita (to remove chlorine and other nasty chemicals) and fill up your own bottle at home! Part of being a good steward to the environemt is just being prepared.

However, having tried FIJI water last month--quite by accident--I ordered water in a bar and they brought me this square bottle with a beautiful lable. I thought to myself, "how stupid is that, that they ship this water all the way from FIJI!" I was astounded at how wonderful it tasted. I have never tasted such amazing water in my life. It has a very high silica content which makes it incredibly smooth to drink. There is absolutely no comparison to bottled spring water. It was what water should taste and feel like. I wish I could drink it every day! It was such a treat!

jump to top Allison says:

not to mention that this is an island,in the middle of a salty sea, pumping fresh water out of the aquifer. yes it will be replenished probably over 100's (maybe thousands)of years. the pumping of ground water ultimatly effects surrounding river,lake and well levels. this is short term financial gain at the expense of the enviroment and the people who must live there long after the ohio CEO has long gone.

jump to top bill elliott says:

i just sort of stumbled on to this conversation. i didnt know plastic was bad. can someone catch me up on whats going on here?

jump to top Mitch says:

Fiji water is the best water around period, no questions asked. The stuff is the water of the gods, I could founder myself on it. Love it. Try it before knocking all bottled water as not worth it.

jump to top Shadus says:

Yeah Fiji is great water, but I don't think that you get the point that people are trying to make about how bad bottled water is as an industry.You have to look beyond the personal gain to the real cost of that great tasting water. It sounds like you would be a great CEO of a corporation though.

My suggestion: If you would like to drink Fiji water every day, move to Fiji I hear it's beautiful there.

jump to top Cin says:

Well, I don't know about any of you, but my tap water has been tasting much more like chemicals these days than water.... and sometimes if I do not run the tap water for a few minutes the water is very cloudy and has floating particles in it. I do drink my tap water, but I found that I prefer not to have that chemical taste. Who wants to put all those chemicals into their bodies? So, tell me again why I should not drink spring water that comes in those plastic bottles?

jump to top AmyV says:

where can i purchase Voss water in toronto?

jump to top devante says:

Its really nice that there are ppl out there that think about all the waste we create and plastic is definately one of them. I think that we can all do our part to make a differnce. I recent purchased a water purifier which is 100% natural and an awesome alternative to buying plastic bottled water. The purifier is made by Stefani and is very easy to use and maintain. Made from terracotta clay, the purifier is totally biodegradable and get this, it cools the water naturally without consuming any electric power! How neat is that. If you want to know more about stefani products, just visit their website: www.stefaniterracotta.com.

jump to top Jason says:

We used to live near an artesian spring in Indiana - so you don't have to buy it from Fiji to get that great taste! However - I do find myself buying every now and again. I love that water - hate the waste!

jump to top Jeannie says:

I work for a small company that manufactures a unique hydration bottle that relly helps stop the waste.
We have charcoal activated filter( made from coconut shell) that turns tap water into bottled water. Just fill up the bottle, close the top and sip away.Every sip is filtered. Thje replacable filter is good fo 80-100 refills. Thats 80-100 toss-out bottles not in the landfill.
We wer recently featured on groovy green.

jump to top Joe Star says:

Bula everyone! Very interesting read! I reside in Fiji and am conducting a research and I stumbled on this site. Anyways my little contribution that I'd like to add... I agree that the world should substantially lessen its use and wreckless disposal of plastics. I also agree that humanity has the right to clean and safe drinking water. However the questions at hand are; bottled water contribute massively to pollution and waste (including waste of resources such as fuel, etc) and, it may eventually lead to humanity being denied access to this vital resource because of the privatization of them.>>>>> I reckon that we have control over these things. People can control how they dispose of plastics, they can control the sale of their natural resources to companies which might exploit the resource> it all comes down to the individuals; who they are, want they want or need, their morals and ethics, values, their culture and traditions, etc. The actions they choose to take may be because of their need for money. It may be for their survival. It puts to debate which is more important at this time...life or the environment. BUT I know that for our survival, we need the environment to survive. So should it be narrowed down to human behaviour? Where we put emphasis on the need of money to survive?? It's been embeded in us that even though we may contest it, we go along with it, yes? Oh yes and as for the disposal on plastics and the types of plastics...maybe people should try and rid the world of the worst types of plastics. Maybe they should altogether come up with effective worldwide programs that will rid the planet of plastics especially plastic bags!!!!! And just a thought> maybe some plastics can "survive" in our lives> such as water bottles> we should be innovative about the uses of them> re-fill- besides, havent people thought of boiling their drinking water? Ok some may oppose this because boiling it may/will use more fossil fuels...>which is better? waste?... sop as I was saying maybe we can compromise...?...maybe...

>Cheers

jump to top Jaclyn says:

IT DEPENDS ON WHERE YOU LIVE. There are plenty of municipal water systems that pump disgusting well water to your faucet. If you live in these areas, bottled water is really your only option -- unless you want to drink chlorine, nitrates, and other disgusting residue. The City of Davis, California is one example. And in Washington, D.C. we receive regular notice from the local government about how our water "might be red" from month to month due to lead and rust falling from pipes. And it continuously smells like sewer water.

Give me my Volvic any day.

jump to top J.D. says:

It is so disturbing about the amount of waste. Not just the plastic from the bottles but how about the amount of water wasted to make the bottles. Or the fuel that is used to truck these heavy bottles across the country. Bottled water has only had a negative impact on our environment. I love the mason jar idea. You can also find great stainless steel bottles at www.waterenlightened.com.
There really is no such thing as "garbage"

jump to top Tracyaz says:

really good article.
:D
i'm having a project for math,
and my driving question is:
if each family were to buy a water filter for their regular drinking water use,
how many water bottles would that save from being dumped in the land fills?

my driving force is to try and persuade people to see my point and buy water filters.

if you can,
i would like to know as well
how many water bottles does an average family use each day?

thanks much.
:)

jump to top sydsyd tululup says:

JUST 2 TELL U PEOPLE IF U DRINK 2 MUCH WATER IT CAN RECE YOUR TEETH BUT WELL ALL LOVE IT SO WHAT CAN WE DO ABOUT SIMPLY DONT DRINK SO MUCH WATERAND THN IT COULD HELP KEEP THE PEOPLE IN AFRICA ALIVE

jump to top ((lois)) says:

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

th ads
th top picks
th ads