most popular: Sex in Small Cars?


most popular:
Killer Smog Clouds


th comments
garrygolden said: "We have been watching BYD's evolution for some time now... your post makes many excellent points re: the opportunities and real world chall..." [read]

Robin from Green Energy Efficient Homes said: "One reason Canada's performance is so pathetic is the oil tar sands, which have grown monstrously in the past ten years because of increasing deman..." [read]

Evan said: "Perhaps you didn't read or understand what Ricardo P. said. If you checked with, even if you double checked with a designer having no knowledge of ..." [read]

Karsten said: "You have to somehow be able to disconnect that belt to be installed in a regular framed bike, or at least be able to separate the rear frame triang..." [read]

Jaymi said: "You both bring up very valid points of concern. And you're right, it is important to consider issues of toxicity when purchasing jewelry that uses ..." [read]

Are McMansions going out of style?

by Lloyd Alter, Toronto on 10. 3.05
Design & Architecture (less is more)

mcmansion.jpg We who preach that less is more liked the article in the New York Times that discussed how more people are looking at the quality of what they buy rather than the size. They point out that with fuel prices rising, smaller and more efficient makes sense, and "plywood palazzos" thrown up with cheap materials are losing their appeal. ::New York Times (free subscription may be required) and be sure to watch the slide show.

Comments (8)

What's wrong with plywood?

jump to top Lee Gibson says:

My wife and I are house-hunting. "I don't want a mansion," said my wife, "I'd just have more space to keep clean."

We've found a small-ish, well-constructed townhome that's in a nice neighborhood in a small city in Amish country, in our price range, less than a mile from my job, a farmer's market and less than two blocks from a grocery store, a bakery and a pub.

Yup. We got real lucky.

I certainly hope so. In urban parts of Northern Virginia, it's hard to find a home built after 1990 that's less than 5,000 square feet.

Toll Brothers, one of the largest builders of McMansions reports that their highest volume model is now 4,800 square feet, while WCI, another large builder, says their most voluminous seller is 5,425 square feet (WSJ, April 2005).

Is this really a reasonable volume of space for a single family home?

jump to top Scott says:

Yes, and Toll Brothers will charge you for the privilege of getting on the WAITING LIST to write a contract to build one of their homes. We're also seeing in NoVA early 20th century housing torn down to make room for these McMansions. When will it stop?

jump to top gretchen says:

i stopped reading when the story said "we are limiting ourself to 3500 square feet"

*rolls eyes*

jump to top m says:

Paging Sarah Sunsanka, come in Sarah Susanka!

jump to top Ailsa Ek says:

Hahahaha! My wife and I have four kids, and just moved this year out of a 950 square foot 3 BR Ranch we owned for 12 years into an 1800 square foot 4 BR 1916 Craftsman boarding house.

We DO live in a McMansion NOW! It's nice that when the kids are in their rooms we don't have to hear every whisper. Of course 1800 SQ/FT isn't much by today's standards, even less with 4 kids. It's HUGE to us.

jump to top Tony says:

I really don't think there isn't a problem with these McMansions. I can understand the social and environmental problems associated with these supersized houses. On the other hand as someone who lives in a small house, it can be a nightmare with a growing family.

The moral of the story is, consumers should have the right to decide where they live. If governments tell us how to live, well that sounds like communism to me.

jump to top Rohan Fisher says:
th ads
th top picks
th ads