most popular:
66 Gas Saving Tips



most popular:
7 Best Electric Scooters


th comments
Mad Marcus said: "The United States has a responsibility, in my opinion, to lead on issues such as environmental protection. You could argue that it's pointless if ..." [read]

Kim said: "I agree with the two comments above. So much of China's pollution comes from the manufacture of goods for the West, and things like cars (which the..." [read]

Paul E said: "I'm a retired guy with a 2008 Prius. They are not equipped with low resistance tires. I've compared mileage with the original tires to the replacem..." [read]

Leslie @ the oko box said: "Dogs should be on a leash , period. I have seen more then one accident happen with dogs who were allowed to run around off their leash, because the..." [read]

H20CarChick said: "I have been trying to ascribe by the "two mile" rule: Anything under 2 miles, I hoof or bike it. I also downgraded by truck 2 years ago to a Volks..." [read]

Today Show: Real-world impacts of driving a hybrid

by on 05.25.05
Cars & Transportation

great-american-gas-01.jpgHybridBlog followed the Today Show's "Great American Gas Challenge": The idea was to have three families take a vacation across the US with the same budget but each in a different type of vehicle (one of them being a Civic hybrid) to see the real-world effects on their vacation. All of this started because of a survey which showed that 60% of US families are changing their vacation plans because of "high gas prices" (good thing they're not driving in Europe). They approached the hybrid's characteristics from pretty much only the monetary angle, but if the mainstream is going to be convinced it's probably going to take at least that.

The results are not surprising, but they have the advantage of being more tangible than mpg figures and estimated dollar amounts over a long period of time. This is all over the course of a 6 day vacation, starting in Los Angeles and ending in New-York.

great-american-gas-02.jpg

Total amount spent on gas
Rileys (SUV): $459.27
Fowlers (Midsize): $277.98
Pletchers (Hybrid): $172.67
Gas Mileage
Riley Family (SUV): 17 mpg (estimate was 15 mpg)
Fowler Family (Midsize): 26 mpg (estimate was 25 mpg)
Pletcher Family (Hybrid): 42 mpg (estimate was 40 mpg)

Since they were all on the same budget, the gas-money difference had an impact on the type of vacation they had. It's a bit sad that in this case the savings were used to do very un-treehugger things, like take a helicopter tour instead of a jeep tour at the Grand Canyon (why not walk and really take the time to see things?), but that money could very well have been spent more wisely, like on organic food and quality hiking equipment, or just not spent at all.

::Great American Gas Challenge, via ::HybridBlog

[by MGR]

Comments (2)

Apparently, people care more about their wallets than the environment. So, i suggest to either make the helicopter run on hydrogen or something, or make the ride hideously expensive. Both will help save the environment.

jump to top Toon says:

Hi,
This is Brian, one of the family members that drove the Hybrid Civic across the country. If the readers here don't mind indulging me, I would like to tell you a little about the trip and the decisions we made.

The grand canyon tour (and lodging) was the only event that was arranged by NBC. Since we left Santa Monica at 3PM on a FRIDAY AFTERNOON we were delighted that it was prearranged - even if it wasn't the most ecologically 'green' thing to do. For those not familiar with the traffic we faced on our 464 mile first leg of the 6 day trip, it took us 4 hours to travel the first 53 miles (Ontario, CA) where we stopped for a quick break and some subway sandwiches.

We didn't get into Grand Canyon until 2AM and had originally been scheduled for a 8AM flight (which meant we had to get up at 5). I say this not to complain - we had a great time on the trip, but to put things into perspective. As much as we wanted to be the "green family", we found the real challenge not to be what we spent at the pumps, nor the obvious benefits of the hybrid Civic, but merely to stay awake and make our daily destinations safely and on time for the morning segment on the Today Show. The producers of the show generally did a great job of planning the trip, however all of them are in their 20s and are not familiar with, nor have ever traveled with children. So they likely figured something along the lines of: "mapquest says 464 miles should take 7 hours, 8 minutes so if they stop for gas and a bite to eat they will be in Grand Canyon by 11PM". With young children in a small cars, frequent stops to get out and run and play are a MUST.

Our family did several things to focus OUR attention on the "Green" aspects of our adventure. We attempted to recycle, however found facilities for this few and far between in our travels across the country. Most places we asked looked at us as if we were crazy when we asked where the recycling bins were.

The most stunning example of a wasted opportunity for recycling was on our return flight home. We flew Delta Song airlines and we and the other passengers were served (several times) the small bottles of water our family tries to stay away from (we prefer refillable sport bottles). Although this likely represented the majority of the waste generated on this flight, we were stunned to find that they didn't bother to separate and recycle the bottles. We asked about it and were met with the same blank stare we got across the country when searching for a recycle bin.

We were sensitive to the 'non-green' aspects of a helicopter tour, and when we woke up at 5AM (and wisely rescheduled the tour to a later time) we found that we could upgrade to state of the art, quieter, more efficient helicopter - which we did. See wwwDOTpapillonDOTcom/index.php?cPath=34_41 (link omitted as this is not an ad) for details.

If NBC had the time to examine the other stops we made they would have found us: walking in the woods of Michigan (we couldn't get out of Chicago soon enough), stopping at a small diner in Amish country in Pennsylvania, spending our extra money in small family run shops when possible, visiting the "old town museum" and "Kit Carson County carousel" in Burlington, CO. and shopping in markets and eating whole food, instead of wastefully packaged fast foods.

Although impressed with the performance and relative comfort of the Civic Hybrid, as I mentioned on the show, I was more interested in the simplicity and low emissions of the natural gas version of the Civic. We went and test drove one today, and I am still not convinced it is the right vehicle for us. If I commuted more than 8 miles, or had a need to be a single rider in the carpool lane, it would be a no-brainer. However, since this isn't the case, it is hard to swallow the nearly $6000 premium and complete lack of choices of accessories this car offers. For 22,000, it is a pretty bare bones car. For the amount of emissions I would save with my 16 mile commute, I think my 'green' could make more of a green difference in other ways, like insulating our house by putting in double-pane glass. I could do that and still buy a fairly loaded gas version of the Civic, which is still much cleaner than my older model Toyota wagon. I really wish that NGV's were more available and reasonably priced.

Although in general I believe that the sort of anti-punitive "act right, or it will cost you" aspects of the Today show gas challenge needn't have been the focus (and aren't a good way to get people to "see the light") I was delighted to participate in anything that underscores what's wrong with this country's need to guzzle gas for no real reason.

Sure, the world would be a better place with more people living like the Amish we visited, but think the everyone has to do what they can - within reason - to prolong the life of our planet. I am proud to have convinced the organizers of our city's earth day several years ago to have recycle bins more readily available. But I don't want you to get me wrong, we do take airplanes when it makes sense, and sometimes take vacations in a motorhome, and did enjoy the helicopter tour, but also try to make a difference whenever possible and are mindful of our consumption.

Signed,
OK, maybe not a tree hugger - but a tree lover,
Brian Pletcher

jump to top Brian says:

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

th ads
th top picks
th ads